Setting up a private practice is a significant milestone for doctors. A crucial early decision is choosing the right business structure. This choice can have long-term implications for everything from tax efficiency and asset protection to future growth and succession planning. While many doctors understandably focus on minimising tax, it’s vital to remember that a sound business structure considers a wider range of factors. A structure driven purely by tax minimisation can be seen as tax avoidance, and may not be the best long-term strategy. This article explores the key considerations and common structures used by medical professionals in Australia.
Key Considerations for Medical Practice Structures
Before deciding on a structure, doctors should carefully weigh the following:
- Asset protection: How can personal assets be shielded from business liabilities, and vice versa?
- Profit distribution: How will profits be shared among owners or partners?
- Growth strategy: Will the structure accommodate future expansion or the introduction of new partners?
- Investment and funding: Will the structure facilitate attracting investment or securing loans?
- Tax optimisation: How can tax liabilities be legally minimised while complying with regulations?
- Succession and exit strategy: How will the practice be managed in the event of retirement, death, or partner departure?
- Personal circumstances: Are there specific personal factors, like family involvement, that influence the choice?
Choosing the right structure requires a thorough understanding of the advantages and disadvantages of each option. It’s highly recommended to seek professional advice from a tax advisor specialising in the medical industry, and potentially a lawyer, before making any decisions.
Common Business Structures for Medical Practices
Sole Trader
This is the simplest and often the least expensive structure, making it a common choice for individual practitioners, particularly those working under contracts with hospitals or other practices. As a sole trader, the business is not a separate legal entity from the individual. While a business name can be registered, it’s not compulsory, and many doctors operate under their own name. A sole trader can employ others but cannot employ themselves.
- Tax Implications: Profits are included in the individual’s tax return and taxed at personal rates. Superannuation contributions are made personally, not as an employer. Losses may be offset against other income, but non-commercial loss provisions may apply. Small business concessions may be available.
- Asset Protection: There’s no legal distinction between personal and business assets, meaning personal assets are at risk for business debts. Conversely, business assets are vulnerable in personal legal matters.
- Other Considerations: Raising capital is difficult, as is transferring ownership. The business ceases to exist if the owner dies or becomes bankrupt.
Partnership
This structure involves two or more people running a business together. While partnerships are relatively simple to set up, disputes between partners can be complex. A comprehensive partnership agreement is essential, outlining roles, contributions, dispute resolution, and dissolution procedures. Partnerships are governed by state-based Partnership Acts. While once common in medical practices, partnerships are less popular today due to joint and several liability and complexities around partners joining or leaving.
- Tax Implications: The partnership itself doesn’t pay tax but lodges a tax return. Income is distributed to partners and taxed at their individual rates. Losses are also distributed. Capital gains are assessed to the partners. Small business tax offsets may be available. Partners cannot be employees of the partnership.
- Asset Protection: Partners are jointly and severally liable for business debts, putting personal assets at risk. Partnership assets are also vulnerable if a partner faces financial difficulties or relationship breakdowns.
- Other Considerations: Changes in partnership membership technically dissolve the old partnership and create a new one, though the same ABN and TFN can often be used.
Company
A company is a separate legal entity, owned by shareholders and run by directors. It can enter contracts, own assets, and incur debts independently. Companies are registered with ASIC and have an ACN.
- Tax Implications: Company income is taxed at a flat rate (currently 25% for Base Rate Entities and 30% for other corporate entities). Dividends distributed to shareholders are taxed at their individual rates, with franking credits potentially applying. Division 7A rules prevent shareholders from extracting profits without paying tax. Capital gains concessions are different for companies, and losses stay within the company.
- Asset Protection: Shareholders have limited liability, protecting personal assets from company debts. However, this doesn’t protect doctors from liability for their own negligence.
- Other Considerations: Companies can raise capital by issuing shares. Ownership can be transferred easily. Companies have higher setup and running costs, including ASIC fees. Directors have specific legal responsibilities and can be personally liable for certain company debts, particularly unpaid tax obligations.
Trust
A trust is not a separate legal entity but a relationship where a trustee holds property for the benefit of beneficiaries. Trusts are often used for asset protection and income distribution flexibility. The trustee (which can be a company) operates the business on behalf of the trust. Common types include discretionary, unit, and hybrid trusts.
- Tax Implications: Trusts don’t pay tax but must register for TFN and ABN. Income is distributed to beneficiaries and taxed at their individual rates. Capital gains discounts and other concessions can be passed through to beneficiaries. Losses remain within the trust. Discretionary trusts offer flexibility in income distribution. Unit trusts distribute income proportionally to unit holdings.
- Asset Protection: Trusts can offer strong asset protection, especially when structured correctly.
- Other Considerations: Trusts can be complex and expensive to set up and run. Legal advice is essential. Trustees have specific responsibilities.
Structuring Medical Practices: Key Questions
Choosing the right structure is a highly individual process. Doctors should consider the following questions and discuss them with their accountant:
- Will I be working alone or with partners?
- How will I fund the practice?
- Will family members be involved?
- How will profits be distributed?
- Will I employ staff?
- Will I engage associate doctors?
- What are the risks involved, and how can they be mitigated?
- Will I purchase premises or equipment?
- Do I have significant personal assets?
- What are the implications of a family breakdown?
- What are my long-term plans for the practice?
- How important is it to retain control?
- Can the practice operate profitably without me?
Personal Services Income (PSI) and Medical Practices
Because medical practitioners earn income from their skills and expertise, it’s considered Personal Services Income (PSI). PSI rules are designed to prevent income splitting and alienation. This means that income earned by a medical practitioner, even if through a company or trust, is generally taxed in the hands of the individual providing the service in the same income year. This also impacts how profits can be retained within a company structure. Professional advice is crucial to navigate these complex rules.