The value of franking credits in a distribution to a member depends on the member’s tax profile. Some taxpayers can fully utilise franking credit benefits, while others cannot.

Who Can Fully Utilise Franking Credits?

The following taxpayers can generally fully utilise franked dividend benefits:

  • Australian resident individuals
  • Australian resident company shareholders
  • Australian resident superannuation funds
  • Exempt institutions eligible for franking tax offset refunds

Who Cannot Fully Utilise Franking Credits?

The following taxpayers generally cannot fully utilise franked dividend benefits:

  • Foreign residents paying final withholding tax at a treaty rate (generally up to 15%)
  • Tax-exempt bodies not eligible for refunds

Anti-Avoidance Provisions

Because members have varying abilities to use franking credits, strategies exist to structure dividends to maximize value. However, general and specific anti-avoidance provisions prevent artificial manipulation of distributions. These broad provisions require careful attention to avoid inadvertently breaching them and losing franking benefits.

Categories of Schemes to Maximise Franked Dividend Benefits

Schemes to maximize franked dividend benefits, while varying, can be categorized into four broad types:

1. Streaming of Distributions

Streaming involves disproportionately allocating franked distributions to members who can best use the credits, while others receive unfranked distributions or bonus shares. This often streams franked distributions away from tax-exempt entities ineligible for refunds or foreign resident members toward non-exempt Australian resident members.

While general franking rules aim to prevent “selective franking,” where distributions on membership interests are franked differently for different taxpayers, these rules have been circumvented. Specific anti-avoidance provisions address such schemes:

  • The “benchmark rule”
  • The “anti-streaming rules” — Div 204 ITAA 97
  • “Schemes to provide franking credit benefits” — s 177EA ITAA 1936 (aimed mainly at franking credit trading schemes but also applicable to dividend streaming)

2. Dividend Stripping

Dividend stripping arrangements involve stripping profits from a “target” company in a “tax-advantaged” manner (Taxation Ruling IT 2627).

3. Dividend Washing

Dividend washing is a scheme where a taxpayer obtains multiple franking credits for a single economic interest. This is done by selling an interest after entitlement to a franked distribution and immediately repurchasing an equivalent interest with a further entitlement. The ATO is reviewing arrangements intended to provide imputation benefits to Australian taxpayers (including individuals and super funds) who are not the true economic owners of shares.

4. Franking Credit Trading

Franking credit trading involves transferring franking benefits between taxpayers, with the franking credit ultimately obtained by a taxpayer who doesn’t bear the full economic risk and rewards of share ownership.

Leave a Reply