“Negative gearing” occurs when the deductible expenses associated with acquiring and holding an income-producing investment exceed the income earned from the investment. The resulting net loss is then offset against other assessable income of the taxpayer.

Negative gearing of a rental property is usually achieved by financing the acquisition with a high level of debt relative to equity. This results in substantial interest expense which, combined with other holding costs, exceeds the assessable rental income.

How Negative Gearing Works in Australia

The ability to negatively gear a rental property in Australia is facilitated by two aspects of our taxation law:

  1. There is no limit on the amount of deductions that may be legitimately claimed in relation to a rental property, as long as the deductions and income arise from “arm’s length” transactions.
  2. A taxpayer may offset a tax loss from a rental property against income earned from other investments or from the taxpayer’s personal exertion income. There is no quarantining of such tax losses and income between different activities carried on by a taxpayer.

Economic Rationale for Negative Gearing

For negative gearing to make economic sense, a taxpayer must believe that the present, after-tax value of current and future losses will be more than offset by the present, after-tax value of future income and capital gains derived from the property.

This usually requires a relatively high level of appreciation in the capital value and, subsequently, the rental income of the property. The tax laws in Australia facilitate this “after-tax” outcome because:

  • The ability to offset current tax losses against other income reduces the effective after-tax cost of current losses.
  • The preferential treatment of capital gains (such as indexation and averaging before 21 September 1999, and the CGT discount for individuals and trusts (in ITAA 1997 Div 115) thereafter) increases the relative after-tax value of any future gains.

Limitations on Interest Deductibility

It’s important to note that interest will not be deductible:

  1. If it cannot reasonably be said that the anticipated future assessable income from the rental property will, at some time in the future, exceed the allowable deductions (including interest) associated with the rental property (Fletcher v FCT 91 ATC 4950). While the history of rental returns in Australia generally supports the expectation of increased future rentals as property values appreciate, if the arrangement’s structure makes it unlikely that rental income will ever exceed deductions (e.g., a rent-cap), the excess deductions will be disallowed.
  2. If the property is purchased to derive a future capital gain and not to eventually earn assessable income exceeding the deductions.

Risks of Gearing

While high levels of debt can magnify after-tax returns when a property appreciates, gearing can also substantially magnify after-tax losses if the investment performs poorly.

Leave a Reply